Category talk:Blue flags with 1 white cross
Jump to navigation
Jump to search
This discussion of one or several categories is now closed. Please do not make any edits to this archive.
Flags with crosses (various categories)
[edit]I hope I've done this right - if not, apologies (I've nominated groups of categories for discussion on en.wiki, but never here before).
The following flag-related categories all seem to have peculiarly ungrammatical names. I propose
- Category:Flags with black one-cross rename to Category:Flags with one black cross
- Category:Flags with blue one-cross rename to Category:Flags with one blue cross
- Category:Flags with red one-cross rename to Category:Flags with one red cross
- Category:Flags with white one-cross rename to Category:Flags with one white cross
- Category:Flags with yellow one-cross rename to Category:Flags with one yellow cross
- Category:Blue flags with white one-cross rename to Category:Blue flags with one white cross
- Category:Red flags with white one-cross rename to Category:Red flags with one white cross
- Category:White flags with red one-cross rename to Category:White flags with one red cross
- Category:Black flags with one-cross rename to Category:Black flags with one cross
- Category:Blue flags with one-cross rename to Category:Blue flags with one cross
- Category:Green flags with one-cross rename to Category:Green flags with one cross
- Category:Purple flags with one-cross rename to Category:Purple flags with one cross
- Category:Red flags with one-cross rename to Category:Red flags with one cross
- Category:White flags with one-cross rename to Category:White flags with one cross
- Category:Yellow flags with one-cross rename to Category:Yellow flags with one cross
- Category:Flags with one outlined-cross (center-parted) rename to Category:Flags with one outlined cross (center-parted)
- Category:Flags with one outlined-cross (center-parted, tricolor) rename to Category:Flags with one outlined cross (center-parted, tricolor)
- Category:Flags with one outlined-cross (center-parted, four-color) rename to Category:Flags with one outlined cross (center-parted, four-color)
I think that's the lot... Grutness (talk) 13:44, 28 August 2022 (UTC)
Support most, but the last three. The incorrect use of parenthesis for non-dab info can be fixed easily:
- Other than these three, all good. Josh (talk) 20:14, 23 December 2022 (UTC)
- That sounds like an improvement on my original suggestion. Thanks, Josh. Grutness (talk) 11:06, 29 December 2022 (UTC)
Question @Grutness: I was about to close and implement this but realized I overlooked one issue. Category names should use digital numbers vs. words to represent quantities (e.g. "1" is better than "one")--see Category talk:Groups for some related discussion on this. Thus, would you have any issue with replacing "one" with "1" in the above list? Josh (talk) 08:05, 5 January 2023 (UTC)
- None whatsoever. I'd assumed the same system as used in Wikipedia articles (words up to ten, numerals thereafter) applied here as well. Whichever is in line with Wikimedia MOS is fine by me as long as it's more grammatical than it is currently! Grutness (talk) 11:47, 5 January 2023 (UTC)
- That sounds like an improvement on my original suggestion. Thanks, Josh. Grutness (talk) 11:06, 29 December 2022 (UTC)
- Adjusted list:
- Category:Flags with black one-cross rename to Category:Flags with 1 black cross
- Category:Flags with blue one-cross rename to Category:Flags with 1 blue cross
- Category:Flags with red one-cross rename to Category:Flags with 1 red cross
- Category:Flags with white one-cross rename to Category:Flags with 1 white cross
- Category:Flags with yellow one-cross rename to Category:Flags with 1 yellow cross
- Category:Blue flags with white one-cross rename to Category:Blue flags with 1 white cross
- Category:Red flags with white one-cross rename to Category:Red flags with 1 white cross
- Category:White flags with red one-cross rename to Category:White flags with 1 red cross
- Category:Black flags with one-cross rename to Category:Black flags with 1 cross
- Category:Blue flags with one-cross rename to Category:Blue flags with 1 cross
- Category:Green flags with one-cross rename to Category:Green flags with 1 cross
- Category:Purple flags with one-cross rename to Category:Purple flags with 1 cross
- Category:Red flags with one-cross rename to Category:Red flags with 1 cross
- Category:White flags with one-cross rename to Category:White flags with 1 cross
- Category:Yellow flags with one-cross rename to Category:Yellow flags with 1 cross
- Category:Flags with one outlined-cross (center-parted) rename to Category:Flags with 1 center-parted outlined cross
- Category:Flags with one outlined-cross (center-parted, tricolor) rename to Category:Flags with 1 tri-color center-parted outlined cross
- Category:Flags with one outlined-cross (center-parted, four-color) rename to Category:Flags with 1 four-color center-parted outlined cross
- Above list adjusted to match discussion. Josh (talk) 19:54, 6 January 2023 (UTC)
This category discussion has been closed. | ||||
---|---|---|---|---|
Consensus | ![]() | |||
Actions | ![]() | |||
Participants | ||||
Closed by | Josh (talk) 17:48, 6 January 2023 (UTC) |