User talk:Rz98

From Wikimedia Commons, the free media repository
Jump to navigation Jump to search

User:ClueBot III/ArchiveThis


Welcome to Wikimedia Commons, Rz98!

-- Wikimedia Commons Welcome (talk) 20:24, 25 February 2021 (UTC)[reply]

License of SVG Cycling Jerseys[edit]

Dear Rz98,

You uploaded a series of cycling jersey SVG icons to Wikimedia Commons. Great work, thanks for that! See the list below for the items it concerns.

However, the shape is exactly the same as the file:Jersey yellow.svg that I created, and uploaded under CC-BY-SA. This means that if you create derivative works', you must

  1. credit the original creator(s), and
  2. share it under the same license

For most of your images, tou did not credit me as the original author of the work you made a derivative of. For some of these images, you did also not use the CC-BY-SA license.


Could you make changes to the images you uploaded? You can do this very simply by adding the following line to the icons you originally created (and removing the current license template line)

{{Self |1= cc-by-sa-4.0|author=Rz98 |attribution= Shape based upon [[:file:Jersey yellow.svg]] by [[User:IIVQ]]}}

{{Template:Change-of-license}} (only for images not licensed as CC-BY-SA)

and if there is a summary table, change the line that reads |source={{own}} with a line that reads something like

|source={{own}} Shape based upon [[:file:Jersey Yellow.svg]] by [[User:IIVQ]]

If you based this icon on another icon than File:Jersey yellow.svg, you can substitute that and credit the creator thereof as well as the authors of the work they based their work on.

See also: User:IIVQ/Cycling Jerseys and Commons:Village pump/Copyright#Cycling Jersey Icons

With regards, IIVQ (talk) 18:51, 9 August 2023 (UTC)[reply]

File Looks like a derivative Date of first upload License User Properly references my work References which work Remarks
Asian Championship Jersey.svg Yes 2022-4-4 CC0 PD Rz98 (talk) No
Oceania_Championship_Jersey_2014.svg Yes 2022-4-6 CC0-1 Rz98 (talk) No
Oceania_Championship_Jersey_2015.svg Yes 2022-4-6 CC0-1 Rz98 (talk) No
European champion jersey 2014.svg Yes 2022-4-8 CC0 PD Rz98 (talk) No
Panam_Championship_Jersey_2016.svg Yes 2022-6-7 CC-by-sa 4 Rz98 (talk) No
Panam_Championship_Jersey_2017.svg Yes 2022-6-7 CC-by-sa 4 Rz98 (talk) No
Panam_Championship_Jersey_2021.svg Yes 2022-6-7 CC-by-sa 4 Rz98 (talk) No
Alt - 2 - Chrono.svg Yes 2022-10-25 CC-By-Sa 4 Rz98 (talk) Yes https://commons.wikimedia.org/wiki/File:Jersey_rainbow_chrono.svg
Jersey_rainbow_thin_piping.svg Yes 2022-10-25 CC-by-sa 4 Rz98 (talk) Yes Modification of Jersey rainbow.svg by IIVQ and others. Version with thinner rainbow piping on the jersey cuffs.
Rainbow_Jersey_E-MTB.svg Yes 2022-10-25 CC-by-sa 4 Rz98 (talk) Other Modification of Jersey rainbow thin piping.svg
Rainbow_Jersey_Esports.svg Yes 2022-10-25 CC-by-sa 4 Rz98 (talk) Yes This file was derived from File:UCI Cycling Esports World Championship rainbow jersey.svg by Tijmen Stam and Hejsa, with thinner rainbow piping on the cuffs
Rainbow_Jersey_Former_Champion.svg Yes 2022-10-25 CC-by-sa 4 Rz98 (talk) Other Modification of Jersey rainbow thin piping.svg
Rainbow_Jersey_Masters.svg Yes 2022-10-25 CC-by-sa 4 Rz98 (talk) Other Modification of Jersey rainbow thin piping.svg
Rainbow_Jersey_Track_Masters.svg Yes 2022-10-25 CC-by-sa 4 Rz98 (talk) Other Modification of Rainbow Jersey Track.svg
Rainbow_Jersey_Track.svg Yes 2022-10-25 CC-by-sa 4 Rz98 (talk) Other Modification of Jersey rainbow thin piping.svg
European champion jersey master.svg Yes 2022-11-5 CC0 PD Rz98 (talk) Other Naar https://commons.wikimedia.org/wiki/File:European_champion_jersey_2016.svg door Maxime de la Guichetière
Rainbow_Jersey_Road_Masters.svg Yes 2022-12-25 CC-by-sa 4 Rz98 (talk) Other Modification of Jersey rainbow thin piping.svg
Panam_Championship_Jersey_2023.svg Yes 2023-6-20 CC-by-sa 4 Rz98 (talk) No
Dear IIVQ,
Thanks for the heads-up, fair enough. I didn't use the yellow jersey, more the rainbow and European jersey as a basis. The latter is also the reason why I placed some jerseys under CC0 as the European jersey was released under that licence. Also, I always credited the work for the content of the jersey, but indeed I did not think about the shape. I'll look into this and let you know when it's taken care of. -- Rz98 (talk) 14:21, 10 August 2023 (UTC)[reply]
Hi Rz98,
Thanks for the reply!
Yeah, in that respect you did nothing wrong, by basing it of file:European champion jersey 2016.svg , because that image was PD. However, that image should've been CC-BY-SA and cite the works they were derived of, which might be one of my jerseys or a whole chain of derivatives. Therefore, it's no more than a friendly request. I am not going to put a lawyer on your head or a deletion request on your images.
The list of your work struck me as a bit weird because some were CC-BY-SA and some were PD, and some images nicely quotes what they were derived on and others didn't. Most others who uploaded multiple images hd all of them with the same construct.
Anyway, thx for your reply - and for your great work! IIVQ (talk) 16:51, 10 August 2023 (UTC)[reply]
Dear IIVQ,
I believe I made the requested changes now, please let me know if it's ok. -- Rz98 (talk) 09:10, 25 August 2023 (UTC)[reply]
Hi Rz98!, I believe you did fix the license on the images that were not in a CC-BY-SA licence, but I don't se an attribution to the original author in most images.
You could fix that by, in the summary table, change the line that reads |source={{own}} with a line that reads something like
|source={{own}} Shape based upon [[:file:Jersey Yellow.svg]] by [[User:IIVQ]]
If you based this icon on another icon than File:Jersey yellow.svg, you can substitute that and credit the creator thereof as well as the authors of the work they based their work on.
Thanx IIVQ (talk) 14:29, 10 September 2023 (UTC)[reply]
Dear IIVQ,
Could you please name the files that are not yet attributed correctly? I believe I litterally applied the changes you requested, but if I overlooked one or two, please let me know. -- Rz98 (talk) 19:11, 26 September 2023 (UTC)[reply]