User:Stefan h~commonswiki

I'm de:Benutzer:Stefan h, get in touch with me on de:Benutzer Diskussion:Stefan h.

Mozart

Unfortunately I have to watch some Mozart portraits, which are spammed by some supporter of Martin Braun (or by himself). In the beginning it seemed that Braun was a free-rider on the Edlinger Mozart Portrait, now he is producing Mozart portraits en masse by providing "studies". His "studies" lack every single scientific approach, nonetheless somebody is massively pushing those Mozart portraits into Wikipedia.

• Banning of 3 sock puppets: [1]
• Administrators' noticeboard/Attention archive "Mysterious paranoia against (unwelcome?) sources"

project	articles and images	users/sockpuppets
commons	User:Stefan h/CommonsArticle User:Stefan h/CommonsImage User:Stefan h/CommonsImage User:Stefan h/CommonsImage User:Stefan h/CommonsImage User:Stefan h/CommonsImage User:Stefan h/CommonsImage User:Stefan h/CommonsImage User:Stefan h/CommonsImage (manipulated image!) User:Stefan h/CommonsImage User:Stefan h/CommonsImage User:Stefan h/CommonsImage User:Stefan h/CommonsImage User:Stefan h/CommonsImage User:Stefan h/CommonsImage	User:Stefan h/CommonsUser User:Stefan h/CommonsUser User:Stefan h/CommonsUser User:Stefan h/CommonsUser User:Stefan h/CommonsUser User:Stefan h/CommonsUser User:Stefan h/CommonsUser User:Stefan h/CommonsUser User:Stefan h/CommonsUser User:Stefan h/CommonsUser User:Stefan h/CommonsUser User:Stefan h/CommonsUser - banned infinite [2] User:Stefan h/CommonsUser - banned infinite [3] User:Stefan h/CommonsUser - banned infinite [4] User:Stefan h/CommonsUser User:Stefan h/CommonsUser User:Stefan h/CommonsUser User:Stefan h/CommonsUser User:Stefan h/CommonsUser User:Stefan h/CommonsUser User:Stefan h/CommonsUser
en	User:Stefan h/Article User:Stefan h/Image User:Stefan h/Image User:Stefan h/Image User:Stefan h/Image	User:Stefan h/User User:Stefan h/User User:Stefan h/User User:Stefan h/User User:Stefan h/User
de	User:Stefan h/Article User:Stefan h/Article User:Stefan h/Image User:Stefan h/Image User:Stefan h/Image User:Stefan h/Image User:Stefan h/Image	User:Stefan h/User User:Stefan h/User User:Stefan h/User User:Stefan h/User User:Stefan h/User (claims to be Braun) User:Stefan h/User
an	User:Stefan h/Article User:Stefan h/Image	User:Stefan h/User (reingefallen)
ast	User:Stefan h/Article User:Stefan h/Image	User:Stefan h/User (reingefallen)
ca	User:Stefan h/Article User:Stefan h/Image	User:Stefan h/User (reingefallen)
cs	User:Stefan h/Article User:Stefan h/Image	User:Stefan h/User (11:10, 19. 4. 2005 (historie) (rozdíl) Wolfgang Amadeus Mozart (An authentic portrait (see documentation behind the image)))
da	User:Stefan h/Article User:Stefan h/Image	User:Stefan h/User (20. apr 2005 kl. 17:05 (historik) (forskel) Wolfgang Amadeus Mozart (An authentic portrait, instead of an inauthentic one (see documentation behind the image)))
el	User:Stefan h/Article User:Stefan h/Image	User:Stefan h/User (reingefallen)
eo	User:Stefan h/Article User:Stefan h/Image	User:Stefan h/User (reingefallen)
es	User:Stefan h/Article User:Stefan h/Image	User:Stefan h/User (15:21 18 abr 2005 (hist) (dif) Wolfgang Amadeus Mozart (An authentic portrait, instead of an inauthentic one (see documentation behind the image)))
fa	User:Stefan h/Article User:Stefan h/Image	User:Stefan h/User (reingefallen)
fi	User:Stefan h/Article User:Stefan h/Image	User:Stefan h/User (20. huhtikuuta 2005 kello 16.21 (historia) (ero) Wolfgang Amadeus Mozart (An authentic portrait, instead of an inauthentic one (see documentation behind the image)))
fr	User:Stefan h/Article User:Stefan h/Image	User:Stefan h/User (18 avril 2005 à 15:43 (hist) (diff) Wolfgang Amadeus Mozart (Two authentic portraits, instead of two inauthentic ones (see documentations behind the images)))
gl	User:Stefan h/Article User:Stefan h/Image	User:Stefan h/User (reingefallen)
he	User:Stefan h/Article User:Stefan h/Image	User:Stefan h/User (reingefallen)
hu	User:Stefan h/Article User:Stefan h/Image User:Stefan h/Image	User:Stefan h/User (2005. április 19., 23:34 (történet) (eltér) Wolfgang Amadeus Mozart (An authentic portrait, instead of an inauthentic one (see documentation behind the image)))
id	User:Stefan h/Article	User:Stefan h/User
ilo	User:Stefan h/Article User:Stefan h/Image	User:Stefan h/User (reingefallen)
ko	User:Stefan h/Article User:Stefan h/Image	User:Stefan h/User (reingefallen)
lv	User:Stefan h/Article User:Stefan h/Image	User:Stefan h/User (reingefallen)
nn	User:Stefan h/Article User:Stefan h/Image	User:Stefan h/User (reingefallen)
no	User:Stefan h/Article User:Stefan h/Image	User:Stefan h/User (20. apr 2005 kl.15:57 (hist) (diff) Wolfgang Amadeus Mozart(An authentic portrait, instead of an inauthentic one (see documentation behind the image))
pt	User:Stefan h/Article User:Stefan h/Image	User:Stefan h/User (22:24, 19 Abril 2005 (hist) (dif) Wolfgang Amadeus Mozart (An authentic portrait, instead of an inauthentic one (see documentation behind the image)))
sh	User:Stefan h/Article User:Stefan h/Image	User:Stefan h/User (reingefallen)
sk	User:Stefan h/Article User:Stefan h/Image User:Stefan h/Image	User:Stefan h/User (reingefallen) User:Stefan h/User (reingefallen)
sv	User:Stefan h/Article User:Stefan h/Image User:Stefan h/Image	User:Stefan h/User (17 april 2005 kl.23.52 (historik) (skillnad) Wolfgang Amadeus Mozart (Ett autentiskt porträtt i stället för ett oautentiskt (se dokumentation bakom bilden))) User:Stefan h/User User:Stefan h/User (reingefallen)
ta	User:Stefan h/Image	User:Stefan h/User (reingefallen)
tr	User:Stefan h/Article User:Stefan h/Image	User:Stefan h/User (reingefallen)
vi	User:Stefan h/Article User:Stefan h/Image	User:Stefan h/User (reingefallen)
zh	User:Stefan h/Article User:Stefan h/Image	User:Stefan h/User (22:53 2005年4月18日 (历史) (差异) 莫扎特 (An authentic portrait, instead of an inauthentic one (see documentation behind the image)))

Facts

ATTENTION - section is incomplete

	images	Persons and Institutions pro	Persons and Institutions contra
"Edlinger"	full portrait - face only	Berliner Gemäldegalerie (Michaelis, Seiller), Edlinger, Braun	rest of the world, Bauer
"Hagenauer"	full portrait - face only	Braun	study is not even commented
"Greuze"	full portrait - face only	Braun	study is not even commented
"Delahaye"	full portrait - face only	Braun	study is not even commented

Persons and Institutions	references
de:Berliner Gemäldegalerie (BGG), owner of the painting, represented by Rainer Michaelis
Seiller, relative to the painter	provided the study for the BGG
Edlinger, relative to the painter
Rolf Schenk	dating the painting "before 1790", hence not from a sitting in 1790
Bauer, Stadtarchiv München	claims there were no time for a sitting in 1790 because of mozarts busy concert schedule, claims also, the painting shows Josef Anton Steiner (1753-1813) Der „Berliner Mozart“ - Notwendiger Widerspruch gegen eine Weltsensation (german) Stadtarchiv München) open letter
Braun	claims to have proven authenticity of the "Edlinger" by biometrics; claims also to have proven authenticity of the "Hagenauer" by biometrics Neurobiologist of unknown qualification Neuroscience of Music, whatever this is expert in ship building of unknown qualification, presents new theory for the Ormen Friske catastrophy and finally, expert in biometrics (Edlinger, Hagenauer Greuze Delahaye) of unknown qualification.

Mr. Braun, en:User:BioMed and de:User:BioMed

Mr. Braun claims to be a neurobiologist, his first publication dates from 1992. Both BioMeds claim to be "In biomedical research since 1992". Mr. Brauns research is focused on "absolute pitch" and "neuroscience of music". Beside Mozart related articles and images en:User:BioMed has edited only in en:Absolute pitch, en:Biophoton and en:Biophotonics. de:User:BioMed has edited Mozart related articles and images and de:Biophoton, de:Biophotonik, de:Cortisches Organ, de:Otoakustische Emissionen and 3 more articles.

Mr. Braun claims to have done scientific studies on two portraits he claims to show Mozart. Both BioMeds show strong interest in Mozart, especially the portraits. de:User:BioMed started the article de:Johann Georg Edlinger the painter of one of these portraits. Both BioMeds refer to the studies of Mr. Braun. en:User:BioMed released the images en:Image:W A Mozart at 21.jpg and en:Image:W A Mozart at 34.jpg to PD, the images are exactly the same as shown on Mr. Brauns website. de:User:BioMed did the same on german wikipedia (de:Bild:W A Mozart at 34.jpg and de:Bild:W A Mozart at 34.jpg).

On german wp de:User:BioMed claims not to be Mr. Martin Braun [5].