Commons:Wiki Loves Monuments 2021/Juries

From Wikimedia Commons, the free media repository
Jump to navigation Jump to search
WLM 2021 Participating countries Uploaded images Organizers FAQ Help desk For organizers
Subpage for Wiki Loves Monuments 2021 organizers.
Instructions for local organizers Knowledge Exchange Landing pages CentralNotice Upload campaigns Lists of monuments Overview of monuments Juries Tools Winners
Notice EXAMPLE 
==COUNTRY NAME==
* Jury organizer/coordinator: USERNAME
===ROUND 1===
*Purpose: Intial filtration
*Jurors:
:*Username 1
:*Username 2
:*Username 3
===ROUND 2===
*Purpose: To decide the top 100
*Jurors:
:*Username 1
:*Username 2
:*Username 3
===ROUND 3 (FINAL)===
*Purpose: To decide the top 15
*Jurors:
:*Username 1
:*Username 2

Germany[edit]

Round 1[edit]

expected Period: 2021-09-01 until 2021-10-12

Round 2[edit]

Ghana[edit]

Round 1[edit]

  • Purpose: To decide top 15 photos
  • Jurors:

Round 2[edit]

  • Purpose: To decide top 3 photos
  • Jurors:

Sweden[edit]

Round 1[edit]

Yes/No to get the number of images down before voting. All images viewed by two jurors and only images with two yes votes moves on.

Round 2[edit]

Rating to get the number of images down before ranking. Remaining images rated by all jurors. Cut off decided soemwhere around 25 images where the score allows.

Round 3[edit]

Ranking to decide on top three and shared 4th moving on to the international finale. If images end up with the same score for top three or making it to the international finale previous rounds decide the outcome.

Italy[edit]

Round 1[edit]

Yes/No to get the number of images down before voting. All images viewed by at least three (or more) jurors and only images with two yes votes moves on.

Republika Srpska[edit]

  • Jury organizer/coordinator: Bojana Podgorica
  • Jury tool: photojury.wikimedia.rs.ba
  • Procedure: internal filtering and review of all photos; selection of photos for the next evaluation; judging by an expert jury team; #TOP10 selection by jury

Jurors[edit]

  • Dušan Milenković - He finished gymnasium in Kragujevac, graduated the Faculty of Philology and Arts in interior architecture. Dušan completed his master studies, module Photography, at the Faculty of Applied Arts in Belgrade. In his professional career he has collaborated with many authors, prestigious magazines and brands, such as Alek Zira, Ellesse, Hugo Boss, Valentino, Jagger, ELLE, Global Foods, Devon Works, Haute Coiffure Francaise, Hello, and many others. In 2006, he won the first prize of the REFOTO magazine at the competition Light and Shadows for photography After Waking Up.
  • Mišo Filipovac - He attended the Art School in Užice, majoring in cultural conservation, graduated the Faculty of Philology and Arts of the University of Kragujevac in wall painting in 2010. Mišo is employed as an assistant professor in Drawing and Nude. He is a member of the Association of Fine Artists of Serbia, which has participated in more than 100 group and international exhibitions. He also had 20 solo exhibitions. In parallel with art, he is actively involved in illustrations and design, collaborating with many prestigious brands and artists.
  • Miloš Petković - He ended his studies in Bajina Bašta, and graduated at the Faculty of Architecture in Varna. Miloš graduated as a Master of Architecture. Since 2014, he has been the architect of numerous public and tourist projects such as tourist complex "Andrićgrad", urban project of the center of the city Bajina Bašta with the park and the square, and the International Rowing Center for the needs of the Balkan Rowing Championship.
  • Darko Gajić - User:Ванилица: He is a long-time Wikipedian, active since 2013, and the author of more than 3,500 articles. He has uploaded over 36,000 photos on Wikimedia Commons.

Ireland[edit]

Pre filtering[edit]

Rebecca does an initial filtering to remove any ineligible photos (photos not containing a listed, protected site).

Round 1[edit]

Yes/No to get the number of images down before voting. All images viewed by two jurors and only images with two yes votes moves on.

Round 2[edit]

Rating to get the number of images down before ranking. Remaining images rated by all jurors.

Round 3[edit]

Final ranking of each jurors top 20 images.

Croatia[edit]

  • Jury organizer/coordinator: Fraxinus
  • Procedure: internal filtering and review of all photos; selection of photos; judging by a jury team; #TOP10 selection by jury

Jurors[edit]

Brazil[edit]

Pre-selection round[edit]

  • Purpose: Initial filtration to minimize the number of photos to the final jury
  • Number of images: 2454 files
  • Type of round: Yes/No
  • Criteria: Receive a "Yes" from at least one judge
  • Notes: Due to the category "Best image of Bahia", all images from that state were automatically selected for the first round. Images contributed by the judges do not participate in any selection
  • Petscan of the selection: https://petscan.wmflabs.org/?psid=20636408
  • Start: 2021-11-12
  • End: 2021-11-13
  • Jurors:

Round 1[edit]

  • Purpose: Filtration of the images that should go to the nest round. Minimize the number of images
  • Number of images: 2823 files
  • Type of round: Yes/No
  • Criteria: Receive a "Yes" from at least one judge
  • Notes: This round included all of Bahia images and the images that received at least one "Yes" on the pre-selection round
  • Petscan of the selection: https://petscan.wmflabs.org/?psid=20650270
  • Start: 2021-11-13
  • End: 2021-11-18
  • Jurors:

Round 2[edit]

  • Purpose: Evaluate the images under the criteria of beauty, technical quality and visual/social impact of the image and/or the monument depicted.
  • Number of images: 1080 files
  • Type of round: Rating
  • Criteria:
  • Receive an average (3 judges) score of 7.5; or
  • Receive an average (3 judges) score of 5.0 if the number of files is too low

Round 3[edit]

  • Purpose: Evaluate the best images under the criteria of beauty, technical quality and visual/social impact of the image and/or the monument depicted
  • Number of images: 100
  • Type of round: Ranking
  • Criteria:
  • List of the 100 images with the lowest score, defined by the mean of the position numbers of the images in the ranking sheet of each judge (4 judges)
  • Notes: This round included all images that received an average score of 7.5 (or at least 4 stars) on round 2
  • Petscan of the selection: https://petscan.wmflabs.org/?psid=20711044
  • Start: 2021-11-22
  • End: 2021-11-26
  • Jurors:

Round 4[edit]

  • Purpose: Choose 10 images for the international jury; Choose the best image from Bahia; Evaluate the best images under the diversity of photographers and images;
  • Number of images: 100
  • Type of round: Ranking
  • Criteria:
  • 10 images with the lowest score (meaning they are in the top 10), defined by the mean of the position numbers of the images in the ranking sheet of each judge (4 judges), considering the diversity of monuments in all 10, and diversity of photographers in the top 5 (the ones that received a prize);
  • 1 image with the lowest score, defined by the mean of the position numbers of the images in the ranking sheet of each judge (4 judges), considering the background of the monuments and the context of the photographs.
  • Notes: This round included all images of round 3 ranked.
  • Petscan of the selection:
  • Start: 2021-11-29
  • End: 2021-11-29
  • Jurors:

Iran[edit]

ROUND 1[edit]

  • Purpose: Intial filtration and removing non-monument images
  • Jurors:

ROUND 2[edit]

  • Purpose: Yes/No for images
  • Jurors:

ROUND 3[edit]

  • Purpose: To decide the top 300
  • Jurors:

ROUND 4[edit]

  • Purpose: To decide the top 40 and get final results
  • Jurors:

Armenia[edit]

Finland[edit]

  • Jury organizer/coordinator: :*Zache
  • Jurors:
Retrieved from "https://commons.wikimedia.org/w/index.php?title=Commons:Wiki_Loves_Monuments_2021/Juries&oldid=765468898"