Commons:Valued image candidates/The Mary Tyler Moore Show

The Mary Tyler Moore Show

undecided

Images	Premiere photo of Gavin MacLeod, 1970. Cast photo: circa 1970 Mary at her desk, circa 1970. Mary with Phyllis and Rhoda, circa 1970. Mary with her boss Lou Grant and co-employee Murray Slaughter, circa 1970. Georgette falling in love with Ted, 1973. Rhoda's father (Harold Gould, left) inviting Mary to the wedding of Rhoda's sister, 1973. (from left) Mary, Rhoda, and Debbie (Rhoda's younger sister) in New York City for Debbie's wedding, 1973 Mary and Rhoda in the kitchen of Mary's apartment, 1973 or 1974. Photo used for 1974 rebroadcast. (from left) Ted Baxter, Phyllis, Mary, and Rhoda awaiting results of Ted's political campaign as the councilman; photo used for 1974 rebroadcast. Lou Grant (right) and his wife on the marital crisis, 1974. Ted discussing wedding plans with his co-workers at Mary's apartment, 1975. Wedding photo of Ted Baxter (Ted Knight) and Georgette Franklin (Georgia Engel), 1975 Lou comforting Sue Ann, whose cooking show was cancelled, taken in 1976. Cast photo: 1977 Rhoda, Phyllis, and Mary reunited at last, 1977.
Description	Photos either used to promote or taken during production of The Mary Tyler Moore Show (1970-77).
Nominated by	George Ho (talk) on 2012-05-01 17:10 (UTC)
Scope	Nominated as the most valued set of images on Wikimedia Commons within the scope: The Mary Tyler Moore Show
Review (criteria)	Comment I think it would be better to break File:Mary Tyler Moore cast 1970 1977.JPG into two files. cmadler (talk) 13:30, 3 May 2012 (UTC)  Info  Splitted two photos. --George Ho (talk) 11:36, 4 May 2012 (UTC)  Question I'm curious why you've included File:Georgia Engel Ted Knight Mary Tyler Moore Show Wedding 1975.JPG but not other photos from the category (File:Priscilla Morrill Ed Asner Mary Tyler Moore Show 1974.jpg, for example). cmadler (talk) 12:27, 4 May 2012 (UTC)  Comment The Ed Asner/Priscilla Morrill one is not the studio potrait but the production still. This nomination only accepts photos whose faces look directly at the camera. --George Ho (talk) 12:45, 4 May 2012 (UTC)  Question On the other hand, may I abandon this restriction and then include production stills? --George Ho (talk) 04:38, 5 May 2012 (UTC) You have the scope listed simply as "The Mary Tyler Moore Show". Just change the description and re-shuffle the photos in the set. cmadler (talk) 22:01, 6 May 2012 (UTC)  Info All changed and expanded to broaden nomination. --George Ho (talk) 23:24, 6 May 2012 (UTC) You might consider creating three derivative files of one photo each from File:Scenes from the Mary Tyler Moore Show 1977.JPG. Also, with the expansion of the scope, it's not at all clear to me why you have chosen to include the photos you have, and excluded the others? cmadler (talk) 12:52, 7 May 2012 (UTC)  Comment  Splitted three images. As for the File:Lisa Gerritsen Bess Lindstrom 1975.JPG, this is used to promote the Phyllis spin-off, but I'm not certain if I want to include it, as she appeared in the Mary Tyler Moore Show earlier. File:Mary Tyler Moore Show title card.jpg — is this eligible? --George Ho (talk) 17:22, 7 May 2012 (UTC) The title card would be good to include, but this copy is probably too low of a resolution (295x221 is pretty low); perhaps you can find a version at higher resolution? The big question for me remains, why these images? For me, there's currently nothing that says that these images (but not any other images) present a comprehensive view of the show. With 21 images currently in Category:The Mary Tyler Moore Show, there are thousands of possible sets we could make. Why is this set the most valuable? cmadler (talk) 18:17, 7 May 2012 (UTC) Well, why wouldn't it? I present photos in a chronological order, but, if this set is too broad, why won't I just split this whole set into many sets as possible, and then withdraw this nomination? I'll split into cast set, set of Rhoda's sister's wedding, Ted and Georgette set, Mary/Rhoda/Phyllis set, <what other sets>? --George Ho (talk) 20:00, 7 May 2012 (UTC) Result: 0 support, 0 oppose => undecided. -- MrPanyGoff 20:12, 11 May 2012 (UTC)