Category talk:Carl Barks
Inappropriate warning...[edit]
User:INS Pirat added a {{NoUploads}} templated to this category, in 2019. That template warns our readers that the works of Carl Banks in this category may not be free, after all.
Maybe the category contained images BY Banks, when it was tagged. However, today, with the exception of his signature, all the images are images OF Banks. The copyrights belong to photographers who seem to have all released those images under a free license.
I think this means the warning is completely inappropriate.
If the commons did have images BY Banks, that were licensed so they could be re-used, I think they would not belong in this category. I think they would belong in a subcategory with a name like Category:Works of Carl Banks. Geo Swan (talk) 23:02, 5 October 2020 (UTC)
- No, the template warns against uploading of Banks' works which are still not free. Why is that "inappropriate"? Without the template, there wouldn't be that warning :) --INS Pirat (talk) 23:26, 5 October 2020 (UTC)