File talk:Arsenal Technical High School.jpg

Historic American Buildings Survey of Indiana and Black and white photographs of Indiana appear appropriate, Towers in Indiana seems better than buildings, as the focus is on the tower, but I left both, though, is there much more that can be done to cat this one ? if not, the buildings should really go. Penyulap ☏ 11:20, 15 May 2013 (UTC)

I'm not sure why Category:Buildings in Indiana or Category:Towers in Indiana would be there. Category:Buildings in Indiana is a redundant (great-grand)parent of existing Category:Brick buildings in Indianapolis; Category:Towers in Indiana is a redundant parent of existing Category:Clock towers in Indiana. (And also, Category:Education in Indianapolis, Indiana is redundant to Category:High schools in Indianapolis.) --Closeapple (talk) 21:23, 15 May 2013 (UTC)

well, that's something I don't understand you see, there is a helpfile, at least I think it is a helpfile, which talks about COM:OVERCAT over-catting. Thing is, I think it's like 'over-acting', that there is no such thing, there is just good acting and bad acting :D

I would sort of think that the best of the best for a category should be in that category and easy to find without the extra clicks. Just today I was trying to find a soyuz launch video, and went to use our category system first, failed completely even though I'm not a complete fool (some parts are missing) and had found it easier to use an external search engine to find exactly what I was looking for on the first try.

Now I'm looking at the image and thinking it's a good looking example of a tower, and so both categories would be cool, but I'm no expert on these things so I'd prefer as much input as I can get. But do please go ahead and do as you want with the categories though, it's all good for me.

I think it would be cool to work out if overcat should be a guideline or policy or what have you, I just don't know enough about it. Most of my uploads are in a big category called 'uncategorised' I think (oops)

Oh, please comment here if you could do me a favour, I would love to get some input from people who do this kind of thing all the time. Penyulap ☏ 07:00, 16 May 2013 (UTC)